This NAS versus repurposed PC cost comparison calculator works out whether building a NAS from an old PC is actually cheaper than buying a dedicated NAS unit. Factors in power consumption, hardware costs, and Australian electricity rates over 5 years.
Find out whether buying a purpose-built NAS or repurposing an old PC is the cheaper option over 3 years — factoring in upfront cost, electricity, and software.
The "use an old PC" argument looks compelling until you run the electricity numbers. A typical old Intel or AMD desktop draws 3–5× more power than a purpose-built NAS. At Australian electricity rates — particularly in SA and WA — that difference adds up faster than most people expect.
Defaults to Australian rates. If you're outside Australia, select your region or enter a custom rate.
| NAS | PC | |
|---|---|---|
| Hardware (upfront) | — | — |
| Software | $0 | — |
| Electricity | — | — |
| Total | — | — |
NAS annual kWh = NAS watts × 8760 hours ÷ 1000. NAS presets use a single 'typical' watt figure (averaged idle/load).
PC annual kWh = (active% × load W + idle% × idle W) × 8760 ÷ 1000.
Annual cost = annual kWh × (rate c/kWh ÷ 100).
Total cost = upfront hardware + software + (annual electricity × years).
Break-even = (NAS upfront − PC upfront − PC software) ÷ annual electricity saving. If the PC costs more upfront, the NAS wins from day 1.
Worked example: DS425+ (32W, $790) vs old Intel desktop (95W load, 45W idle, $0). Moderate (25%/75%). NSW 35c. PC annual = (0.25×95 + 0.75×45)×8760/1000 = 503.7 kWh → $176.3/yr. NAS = 32×8760/1000 = 280.3 kWh → $98.1/yr. Annual saving: $78.2. Break-even: $790 ÷ $78.2 = 10.1 years.
| State | Rate (c/kWh) | NAS Annual | PC Annual | Annual Saving | Break-even |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NSW | 35c | $98/yr | $176/yr | $78/yr | 10.1 yrs |
| VIC | 30c | $84/yr | $151/yr | $67/yr | 11.8 yrs |
| QLD | 30c | $84/yr | $151/yr | $67/yr | 11.8 yrs |
| SA | 42c | $118/yr | $212/yr | $94/yr | 8.4 yrs |
| WA | 31c | $87/yr | $156/yr | $69/yr | 11.4 yrs |
| TAS | 28c | $78/yr | $141/yr | $63/yr | 12.5 yrs |
| ACT | 30c | $84/yr | $151/yr | $67/yr | 11.8 yrs |
| NT | 29c | $81/yr | $146/yr | $65/yr | 12.2 yrs |
DS425+ vs old Intel 8th gen desktop, Moderate usage (25% load, 75% idle). Rates verified March 2026. SA and WA users see break-even under 10 years — meaningful for hardware that lasts 5–8 years. Power pricing in SA (42c/kWh) is among the highest in the developed world. At SA rates, a 100W always-on server costs ~$368/year to run — more than many Synology NAS units cost outright.
NBN upload speeds affect your NAS remote access capability regardless of hardware — see our NBN Remote Access Reality Checker for AU-specific limits. Australian Consumer Law gives you minimum warranty rights on all hardware purchased in Australia.
Back to NAS Tools Hub · HDD vs SSD Running Cost · NAS Power Cost Calculator